A controversial decision has been made to transform a former B&B located directly beneath one of Derbyshire's most renowned and 'giddy' hiking trails into a six-person HMO. The Stone Lodge B&B, situated off the A6 near Matlock Bath, has been closed for a year and is now set to become a HMO, providing three parking spots for its tenants. This move has sparked concern among residents, who argue that the area already faces parking and traffic issues due to its popularity with tourists. Emma Saxton highlights the potential exacerbation of these problems, especially on the busy and constrained A6. Additionally, Adam Nash brings up the history of HMO-related issues in the surrounding area, including police and council action to shut down similar facilities. He emphasizes the difference between B&Bs with constant supervision for short-term guests and long-term unrelated guests without permanent supervision, expressing concerns about the cramped living conditions for future occupants. Councillors also raised concerns, with Cllr Matt Buckler stating that the change is 'not compatible with this area of the village' and that it risks undermining the delicate balance of housing types in Matlock Bath. Cllr David Hughes questioned the safety implications of allowing cars to reverse onto the A6, while Cllr Lucy Peacock acknowledged the issues but emphasized the council's legal and moral obligations to provide housing for young people. The debate continues, with Councillors Peter Slack and Peter Dobbs advocating for the need to provide housing for young people, while also addressing potential anti-social behavior and noise issues through licensing. The decision has sparked a heated discussion, leaving many residents divided on the matter.
